Friday, March 03, 2006

Offending conservatives: Europe, Islam, and the pro-Denmark bandwagon

You know what's funny? American conservatives generally hate Europe. Especially France, of course, but the loathing is generally quite continental. Europe may have given birth to Western Civilization, but now it's a socialist secular wasteland that's rapidly sinking into oblivion and irrelevance, that is, in essence, becoming extinct, dying. At best, conservatives want Europe to be more American, hence their enthusiastic support of Italian conservative Silvio Berlusconi and German conservative Angela Markel. Indeed, it wasn't so long ago that they enthusiastically supported a French conservative by the name of Jacques Chirac.

In being more American, Europe should be, according to a June 2005 Weekly Standard editorial, "a vigorous partner for American foreign policy objectives". An un-American, let alone anti-American, Europe is simply unacceptable (much like an un-American Canada). A Europe that promotes alternative goals, alternative conceptions of the good and the just, simply won't do. Which is why Europe is seen not just as different, but weak by design. Conservatives despise the European Union and find that their best European friend is Poland -- aside from Britain, of course, which conservatives like to believe isn't really European at all.

So how funny it is, in an odd sort of way, to see conservatives falling all over themselves in support of that great European power, Denmark, just because a Danish newspaper published a few provocatively offensive cartoons that belittled Islam (see here, here, and here). It's a case of free speech, conservatives argue, but the fact that speech is free, and ought to remain so, doesn't make it right. Are we witnessing a rush of conservative support to Holocaust-denier David Irving? Not so much. But conservatives are jumping gleefully aboard their self-made pro-Denmark bandwagon -- see here, here, and here.

Great, so a handful of them are courageously taking to the mean streets of New York and Washington in support of their new best friend. Are these rallies really "gatherings of individuals in support of individual freedom," as Andrew Sullivan has put it, or is there not something else, something far more pernicious, going on? Why else come to the defence of such ignorance and insensitivity?

I don't deny that these conservatives seem to love freedom, at least in theory, at least in speech, but they're obviously picking their fights selectively. When the other side is Islam, it must be so much easier for conservatives to reach out to Europe -- sick, weak, dying Europe.

Bookmark and Share

7 Comments:

  • If you see everyone through your own self-definied labels, and things don't add up, maybe your labels and assumptions are wrong.

    1) the cartoons were innocuous.
    2) why do you assume we are "conservatives"? I know some of the people there would call themselves liberals. Concern for civil liberties used to be one mark of a liberal.
    3) why do you assume "conservatives" wouldn't stand up for free speech?
    4) some of us at the rally were asked by media if we thought David Irving should be in jail and we said no.
    5) If some of Europe is sick, we need to support the part that's a bit healthier, and that is standing up for itself in the face of violent threats.

    The world is much bigger and stranger than your stereotypes.

    By Blogger Judith, at 1:26 AM  

  • All Things Beautiful TrackBack The Vikings Hit New York

    "Sorry guys I was not in New York to support the Denmark rally, but will give you some links to the young and the brave who carried the torch. Especially my friend Mike Weiss @ Snarksmith who was responsible for organizing it, and the ever supportive brilliant blogger Pamela @ Atlas Shrugs, and Judith Weiss @ Kesher Talk (and here), who together with 100 or so others, braved the subzero temperatures to attend."

    By Blogger Alexandra, at 2:24 AM  

  • Judith:

    Obviously, there are exceptions, which is why I used the word "generally". Can you deny that there is a good deal of anti-Europe sentiment on the right?

    Were the cartoons really "innocuous". Maybe that's the problem. Too many people don't understand just how insensitive they are.

    I don't assume that all of you are conservatives. But the blogs that have been celebrating the rallies are conservative.

    I do not make the assumption that conservatives don't stand up for free speech. Some conservatives pick their battles selectively, however.

    I realize that some conservatives have come out against Irving's conviction. So have some liberals. But you're not about to hold a rally on his behalf, are you?

    You claim to be supporting the healthier part of Europe. Is Denmark the healthier part? If so, why? Because one of its newspapers published offensive cartoons? Do you approve of anything else Denmark is doing?

    These aren't stereotypes. The right is generally anti-Europe. Rumsfeld has made comments about Europe "old" and "new," for example, and conservatives generally tried to link Kerry to Europe in '04.

    By Blogger Michael J.W. Stickings, at 6:45 PM  

  • why did the conservatives not support freedom of speech for the holocaust denier?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:49 PM  

  • I'm sure most conservatives are well aware Denmark is a Socialist swamp.
    More importantly, is the opportunity to support them in the movement against Islamacreep.
    We all have agendas. Some are more well thought out and productive in the quest to save western civilization - would that include you ?

    By Blogger Cu'cullen, at 10:19 PM  

  • We must seek out the goblet of Saloth Sar and use its mighty powers to summon Kronog Threek. It is our only hope in this noble quest to save the world from enslavement by the forces of pure damnable evil.
    Oh, Evil. Will you never rest?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 11:15 AM  

  • I'm proud to say that I was one of the people who attended the New York City rally in support of Denmark last Friday (I was the one with the Lego constructed "Lego My Free Speech" sign). I consider myself a man of the left, and, to clarify, it's fairly accurate and appropriate for this discussion to label me a "Hitchens style" leftist.

    Judging from the other attendees and the subsequent posts online, it's quite obvious that it was mostly a "conservative" crowd. It's more than disheartening to see the left ignore this opportunity to stand up for liberal democratic values and against, what has been correctly labeled, fascism.

    Chalk up, what was in my opinion, a relatively weak attendance to short notice or little publicity, but the fact that very few liberal/left blogs have reported anything about either the past or planned rallies in support of Denmark is, simply put, an embarrassment. If there was ever an issue that should unite the left and the right I should think it would be this one.

    Fraternally,
    Jerry
    www.njforfeingold.org

    By Blogger frailamerica, at 11:49 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home